VS
Alfa Romeo Tonale vs BMW X1
Do you own one?
Enter your number plate to track it simply, with the free basic plan.
Powertrains and consumption
Alfa Romeo Tonale
Energy profile: Alfa Romeo Tonale is mainly hybrid.
BMW X1
Energy profile: BMW X1 is mainly hybrid.
Consumption comparison
| Energy | Alfa Romeo Tonale | BMW X1 |
|---|---|---|
| Petrol | 9.8 L/100 km | 5.6-9 L/100 km |
| Diesel | - | 4.3-5.1 L/100 km |
These figures reflect official mixed WLTP consumption (min - max) from our catalogue for all powertrains.
Powertrains by generation
Generations with a detailed sheet (story, reliability, servicing). Open a generation to go deeper.
Service costs & insurance
These figures are indicative estimates for a standard service outside the dealer network.
Alfa Romeo TonalePremium
Servicing a Alfa Romeo Tonale sits about 41% above the market average (premium positioning).
- Simple oil change~ 125 €
- Full service~ 405 €
- Front brake pads~ 190 €
- Timing-belt kit~ 825 €
- Tyres (set of 4)~ 495 €
BMW X1Premium
Servicing a BMW X1 sits about 50% above the market average (premium positioning).
- Simple oil change~ 145 €
- Full service~ 440 €
- Front brake pads~ 190 €
- Timing-belt kit~ 945 €
- Tyres (set of 4)~ 450 €
Price shown for belt-driven engines; some versions use a chain (no due date).
Dimensions & specifications
| Criterion | Alfa Romeo Tonale | BMW X1 |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | 1525-1875 kg | 1400-1860 kg |
| Boot volume | 385-765 L | 445-540 L |
| Max boot (seats folded) | 1550 L | 1650 L |
| Power outputs | 130-280 hp | 116-326 hp |
Articles related to this duel
Frequently asked questions
How do you choose between two cars?▾
Compare what costs over time first: reliability (known faults, chain or timing belt), service budget and real-world consumption. The spec sheet rarely separates two cars in the same segment; running costs almost always do.
Which criteria should you compare before buying?▾
The five that weigh most: yearly service cost, documented model weak points, mixed consumption, insurance for your profile, and space (boot, dimensions). Each of our duels puts them side by side.
Where does Garajo's data come from?▾
From our maintenance catalogue: generation-by-generation service plans, documented reliability model by model, and official WLTP consumption. Verdicts are recalculated whenever the catalogue is updated.